Best Italian Restaurant in Sea Girt

Italian plates and martinis in Sea Girt

Order online

Martinis at the bar

We have a martini list and specialty martinis, and you'll find them at the bar up front.

Lasagna and meatballs

If you want old school red sauce, start here. We bring bread and bruschetta to the table while you decide.

See the menu

From the kitchen

Live music on Fridays

The band plays at the bar, and happy hour is a good time to come in. On weekends and in summer, reserve a table.

Parties of 10 to 100

We host groups from 10 to 100 guests, and we can set you up in a reserved space for a birthday or a business meeting.

Plan an event

If you grew up on Jersey Italian food and you know you know. Fratello’s is that place. We started with the stuffed mushrooms. Absolute classic. Then came the artichoke Francese and I’m not exaggerating when I say it might be the best I’ve ever had. Perfect amount of lemony buttery sauce and yes we asked for extra on the side because that bread deserved a dip situation. For mains we did the chicken marsala and the chicken special and both were exactly what you want from an old school Italian…

Taylor C.

Probably one of the best meals my wife and I have had in awhile! Zuppa di Pesce was delicious although I was full I dunked a half a loaf of bread into the broth not willing depart from this delicious dinner My wife order the filet mignon smothered in garlic butter and it was tender and fabulous Lisa our server went above and beyond to satisfy our request!!

charles S.

Our first time dining! We were completely impressed with the incredible food and specialty offerings, plus the drinks were well prepared. Service (Erin) was friendly and very efficient. I was able to maneuver my scooter easily without interfering with the wait staff, that's a big plus, since I cannot easily transfer into a dining room chair. Clams on the half shell plus calamari for starters Grey Goose martinis with Blue Cheese olives, perfect. Veal marsala, Shrimp Andrea and Black Sea Bass…

Ray H.

A hidden gem! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm, festive, and inviting—live music, a lively bar scene, and a staff that couldn’t have been friendlier. They’re well known for their martinis, and rightfully so—every cocktail was perfectly made. For appetizers, the garlic shrimp cooked in Chardonnay wine and served over crostini was outstanding—rich, buttery, and packed with flavor. The Blue Point oysters were incredibly fresh and beautifully presented, making it a full dining…

S S.

If you’re a seafood lover with a serious appreciation for spice, Fratello's Restaurant absolutely delivers. I ordered the spicy Zuppa de Pesce and WOW!! this dish deserves its own spotlight. The seafood was incredibly fresh, perfectly cooked, and swimming in a rich, flavorful broth that had just the right amount of heat. As a self-proclaimed spice queen, I can confidently say this wasn’t just “a little kick”… it was bold, balanced, and downright addictive. My only tiny suggestion? I would…

Stephanie M.

Fratello's Italian Restaurant & Lounge Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join now

Frequently Asked Questions

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer catering?

Yes! Fratello's Italian Restaurant & Lounge offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events.

Visit our catering page for more information.

What payment methods do you accept?

When you order online, we accept credit cards (Mastercard, Visa, American Express, Discover), Apple Pay, and Google Pay.

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Sea Girt, Manasquan, Villa Park, Blansingburg, Spring Lake Heights, Spring Lake, Osbornes Mills, Brielle, Point Pleasant Beach, Manasquan Park, West Belmar, Sterling Woods, Lake Como, South Belmar, Algers Mills, Allenwood, Belmar, New Bedford, Herbertsville, and Riviera Beach.